Tag Archives: scientific-funding

A Terrible Job Advert and Position at Leiden

In my feed is a really awful job advert from Leiden for a six-month PDRA position at Leiden. It immediately annoyed me not only for it not being spell-checked, but for the extreme up-front requirements to apply, and the arrogant and condescending manner which it treats perspective coworkers :

“Your application should include a short motivation letter clearly indicating WHY you apply for this position and project and WHAT makes you a suitable candidate, a CV (including the title and date of your PhD, name of PhD supervisor, and details of any prior postdoctoral/research positions), and at least two letters of reference from you current and prior managers. Applications not meeting these requirements will not be assessed or receive a response.“

Reference letters in advance of selection are not used in the Netherlands; they are an Americanism. What’s more, all a reference letter in the Netherlands can legally state is your dates of employment, your duties and your job title. They’re pretty useless in making a selection.* The normal practice is to list a number of references at the end of the C.V., and they are only contacted after the selection is made. Normally, contact is via a phone call, with no records, and so things that one is not allowed to say can be said.

Intrigued, I looked further into it. The universitair docent (i.e. an Associate Lecturer or Lecturer below the bar) placing advert has an XS grant from NWO. These are grants for 50,000 euros to enable “high risk, high reward” research. How is it going to pay the wages? A curious thing about the XS grant is that it specifies a cost for hiring a PDRA (and other levels), but that cost doesn’t cover the actual cost of employing a PDRA – especially the sort of experienced researcher you’d need to solo a difficult project in six months. I know someone who got an XS recently, and it covered employing a band 9 masters-educated RA for four months, not a band 10 PDRA for six. One thing about Dutch employment law is you cannot waive seniority and accept a lower than statutory payscale, and the employer must pay you according to your seniority.** It’s not like the labs in Oxford which were (when I was there) full of women with Ph.D.’s on research technician contracts.

Whoever gets the position will have six months to run the entire project, and any extension is contingent not only on performance, but additional funding. The project appears to be developing a molecule to degrade a protein involved in metastasis in-vivo – something never achieved before.** Examining the grant-holder’s publications, I can see they’re inexperienced in synthetic chemistry, and I think they’re unfamiliar with how long things take. This is part of the systematic misuse of PDRA’s as project scientists that’s becoming dominant; the PDRA isn’t a trainee academic (what the position is supposed to be), but rather is there to fill in the shortcomings of an academic. Since there is apparently asymmetric synthesis involved, there’s basically time to synthesise and test maybe a small handful of molecules with the bedding in and wrapping up periods. It would not surprise me if, at the end of six months, there is nothing.

Whilst they should faithfully trying to execute the project with a reasonable amount of energy, the best interests of whomever gets the position would be networking and trying to get an embedding guarantee for a Veni or Vidi grant, and applying for other grants in this period. This can be a springboard into greater things.

* This is now the norm. All references are now used for in most employment is to check the applicant wasn’t lying about their employment history. Hence, advanced reference letters become useless, as you still need to independently verify them.

** I’ve seen adverts for UD2 positions (i.e. associate lecturer, the normal entry point into the tenure-track) that specified less than, ISTR, three years since Ph.D. defence. Partially this may be due to the incredibly tight grant cut-offs the NWO gives, but it’s also that the universities cannot afford to hire more experienced staff.