My Ghost Authorships

This is a quick test to see if this still works, as I’ve let it lay fallow.

Recently a paper came out that I should have been an author on, but wasn’t. I knew of a few of these, but I wondered how many ghost authorships I had. The answer that a quick search found ten (10), and in Google scholar they’re been collectively cited 336 times. I will not name them or embarrass anyone.

A ghost authorship, in the way I’m using it here, I’m defining as a paper that would not exist if not for my intellectual input. There are other papers that I helped with interpreting an NMR, doing simple measurements, showing someone how to use a machine etc., but that’s just part of being in a laboratory. Nevertheless, I have seen people given authorships for showing someone how to operate a machine, with no actual intellectual contribution. In many of these cases I’d have been happy with an acknowledgement, but I never got one.

So the question arises; how did these ghost authorships come into being?

The first reason for not listing me as an author is that the Ph.D. student whom I was co-operating with simply didn’t tell their (or our) PI where the intellectual input came from, and instead presented it as their own. Let’s generously assume that this was a lack of understanding of authorship ethics on their part.

The second is that a student or PI decided that they didn’t want to give me an authorship, even in cases where they’d used materials I’d made for their project. In a couple of these cases it had been agreed I was an author, and then I was surprised to see it appear in my feed as work I might be interested in. Their reasons I can but speculate on, but mostly seem to be not wanting to share credit.

Ultimately, many of these papers are, IMHO, fairly low-quality. Three of them would count for h-index, and raise it to twenty-six (26). Another two are very close, and would raise my h-index to twenty-eight (28) in the next few months, assuming my lowest ranked counting paper also came up (as it is only running a few citations per year). The three that are most cited are, despite being in good journals, quite subpar for the journal they’re in, and I would have had a lot of comments on them. Same for the following two.

Leave a Reply